Author ProtectionUpdated

Publishing Contract Red Flags: 21 Clauses to Check Before You Sign

Publishing contract red flags: 21 clauses to check before you sign, from rights grabs and royalty routing to termination, file ownership and auto-renewals.

Vintage Typewriter Composing
Image: Wendelin Jacober via Wikimedia Commons, CC0
On this page
  1. Key takeaways
  2. Rights: clauses 1 to 6
  3. Money: clauses 7 to 12
  4. Files and accounts: clauses 13 to 16
  5. Termination and renewal: clauses 17 to 19
  6. Fine print: clauses 20 and 21
  7. A one-page summary to fill in before you sign
  8. How to ask for changes to a contract
  9. How Cassell Publishers' own terms handle these clauses
  10. How Cassell Publishers can help
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. Sources

The biggest publishing contract red flags are clauses that take more rights than the service needs, route your royalties through the company instead of paying you directly, make it hard to terminate, keep your files, renew automatically or add fees later. Before you sign any publishing or publishing-services agreement, check 21 clauses in five groups: rights, money, files and accounts, termination, and fine print. With Cassell Publishers, authors keep their rights and royalties are paid directly by the retail platforms.

A contract is where a fair deal becomes binding, and also where an unfair one hides. Most authors read the price and skim the rest. This checklist covers the 21 clauses that matter most, grouped so you can work through a contract in one sitting. It complements our guide on how to read a publishing contract, which explains contract structure; this one focuses on the traps.

Key takeaways

  • Rights: grant only what the service needs, for a clear term, with a clear way to get them back.
  • Money: know who receives royalties, how they are calculated and whether extra fees can be added later.
  • Files and accounts: you should receive your final files, and retailer accounts should be yours or clearly transferable.
  • Termination: look for a clear exit, no release fees and no automatic renewals you did not agree to.
  • Cassell Publishers' terms: authors keep their rights, and royalties are paid directly to them by the retail platforms.

Rights: clauses 1 to 6

  1. Grant of rights. Which rights are you granting: print, ebook, audio, translation, film? A services company that produces your paperback has no need for film or translation rights. The Authors Guild's model contract treats the grant of rights as the heart of the agreement for good reason.
  2. Term. For how long? "The full term of copyright" can mean your lifetime plus 70 years. For a services agreement, look for a short, defined term.
  3. Territory. Worldwide rights should match worldwide distribution you are actually getting.
  4. Exclusivity. Can you publish other editions or formats yourself while the contract runs?
  5. Subsidiary rights. Film, TV, audio and translation rights deserve separate, specific terms. Be wary of any company that claims a share of these just for producing your book.
  6. Reversion. Is there a clear rights reversion clause, with defined triggers? "Out of print" definitions based only on availability are a trap, because a print-on-demand book never goes out of print. IBPA expects hybrid publishers to "include a clear rights-reversion clause in every contract."
Clause Fair version Red flag version
Grant of rights Only the formats being produced All rights in all media
Term A defined number of years The full term of copyright
Subsidiary rights Kept by the author unless separately agreed A share of film or translation income for producing the book
Reversion Clear triggers based on sales or time Only when the book is "out of print"

Money: clauses 7 to 12

  1. Royalty routing. Are royalties paid directly to you by the retailers, or collected by the company and passed on? When the company collects, you depend on its reports and its honesty.
  2. Royalty rate and base. Is the rate on list price or on "net", and is net defined? The Authors Guild model contract's royalties section shows how specific a good clause is.
  3. Statements and audits. How often do you receive sales statements, and can you check the numbers?
  4. Payment schedule. Is the full price due before any work starts? Staged payments tied to delivered work protect you.
  5. Additional fees. Can the company add charges later for "upgrades", storage, "processing" or reprints? Every cost should be in the written quote.
  6. Mandatory purchases. Are you required to buy copies, marketing or reviews as a condition of publication?

Files and accounts: clauses 13 to 16

  1. File ownership and delivery. Will you receive the final interior, cover and ebook files, and when? Files you cannot get are files you cannot republish.
  2. Cover and illustration licensing. Who owns the cover art and illustrations? If the designer keeps the rights, can you use them after the contract ends?
  3. ISBN ownership. Whose name is the ISBN registered in? An ISBN identifies the publisher of record for an edition, so know which one you are getting.
  4. Retailer and distribution accounts. Is the book listed through your own account or the company's? If the company's, how is it transferred or removed when you leave?
Letterpress reglets
Image: Michellecornelison via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Termination and renewal: clauses 17 to 19

  1. Termination for convenience. Can you end the agreement with notice? On what terms?
  2. Release and exit fees. Any fee to "release" your rights, files or account is a serious red flag.
  3. Automatic renewal. Does the contract, or a hosting, marketing or "maintenance" fee, renew automatically each year? Auto-renewals should be clearly disclosed, optional and easy to cancel.

Fine print: clauses 20 and 21

  1. Option and first refusal. Does the company get first claim on your next book, or all future books? That is unusual for a services agreement.
  2. Jurisdiction, disputes and reviews. Where would a dispute be heard, and under which country's law? Be wary of clauses that send disputes abroad or try to stop you from posting honest reviews.

IBPA's revised criteria say a reputable hybrid publisher "supplies a clear, negotiable contract at the start of every negotiation" and "welcomes potential authors to discuss the proposed contract with neutral third-party advisors." If a company will not let you take time to read or seek advice, treat that as an answer. Our Author Protection Desk offers a complimentary second opinion on any publishing contract.

A one-page summary to fill in before you sign

Before signing any publishing agreement, write the answers to these questions in your own words. If you cannot fill in a line from the contract itself, ask the company to show you where it is answered, in writing.

Question Your answer from the contract
Which rights am I granting, and for how long?  
Who receives the royalties, at what rate, and how often am I paid?  
What is the total cost, and can any fee be added later?  
Which files will I receive, and when?  
Whose name are the ISBNs and retailer accounts in?  
How do I end the agreement, and what does it cost?  

Keep the completed summary with your signed contract. If anything goes wrong later, it shows exactly what you understood you were agreeing to.

How to ask for changes to a contract

Many authors assume a publishing contract is take it or leave it. A reputable publisher expects questions, and IBPA's criteria describe a "negotiable" contract as a standard. Here is how to ask:

  1. List your questions clause by clause, quoting the clause number.
  2. Say what you want instead, in plain words: "I would like the term to be three years," or "I would like royalties paid directly to my account."
  3. Ask for changes in writing, either as a revised contract or a signed addendum. A promise on a call is not part of the agreement.
  4. Take your time. A genuine limit on places in a program still leaves you time to read. If you are told there is no time to read, there is no reason to sign.
  5. Get advice if the stakes are high. Authors organizations and arts legal programs can help, and our Author Protection Desk offers a complimentary second opinion.

How a company responds to reasonable questions tells you a great deal. A partner explains; a scammer pressures.

How Cassell Publishers' own terms handle these clauses

We hold ourselves to the same checklist. Our terms and conditions state that ISBNs are assigned under the Cassell Publishers imprint unless you elect to supply or purchase ISBNs in your own name, that you retain the copyright and all rights not expressly licensed, and that Cassell acts as publisher of record for distribution purposes only, for the editions it produces.

  • Rights: you keep 100% of your rights.
  • Royalties: you keep 100% of your royalties, paid directly to you by the retail platforms.
  • Files: you receive all of your final files, to take anywhere.
  • Price: every author receives a written, itemized quote before paying, and our pricing page is public.
  • Refunds: our refund policy is published.

Our facts page answers the most common questions, and Our Story explains why we work this way. For the wider picture, read publishing contract rights and royalties and who owns my book?

How Cassell Publishers can help

Send us any publishing contract, ours or anyone else's, and we will tell you plainly what it means. Call (786) 432-2225 or contact our Author Protection Desk for a complimentary contract review.

A fair contract is short on surprises. If a clause would cost you your rights, your royalties or your files, ask for it in plain words, and do not sign until you have it.

Frequently asked questions

What are the biggest red flags in a publishing contract?

Clauses that take more rights than the service needs, route royalties through the company, make termination hard, keep your files, renew automatically or allow fees to be added later. Any fee to release your rights or files is a serious warning sign.

Should royalties be paid directly to the author?

Direct payment from the retail platforms is the most transparent arrangement, because you see every sale yourself. If a company collects royalties for you, the contract should set out the rate, the calculation, statement frequency and your right to check the figures.

What is a rights reversion clause?

A clause that returns your rights to you when defined conditions are met, such as low sales or the end of a term. Definitions based only on whether a book is available are weak, because print-on-demand books never go out of print.

Do Cassell Publishers authors keep their rights?

Yes. Authors keep 100% of their rights and 100% of their royalties, paid directly by the retail platforms, and receive all of their final files. ISBNs are assigned under the Cassell Publishers imprint unless the author elects to use ISBNs in their own name.

How long should I take to review a publishing contract?

As long as you need to understand every clause. A reputable publisher gives you time to read, ask questions and seek advice. If you are told there is no time to read before paying, treat that as a red flag.

Are automatic renewals in publishing contracts normal?

Some services, such as website hosting, renew by design. Any renewal should be clearly disclosed, optional and easy to cancel. Be wary of contracts or fees that renew automatically without a clear notice and an easy way out.

Can someone review my publishing contract at no cost?

The Cassell Author Protection Desk offers a complimentary second opinion on any publishing contract. It is general guidance, not legal advice; for formal legal advice, speak with a licensed attorney or an organization such as Volunteer Lawyers for the Arts.

Share this guide

Editorial policyImage credits

Back to top ↑